So nothing constructive to say then.
This is a constructive thread and people just saying no are not welcome
I am not just saying NO, I am saying why it's NO. As others have already pointed out people are generally selfish and so a voluntary system will not work because the majority of people will not volunteer to pay their supposed dues.
Notwithstanding the usual attitude to anything that isn't critical of any colour other than red when it comes to blaming the "oppressors of the many", I'm not surprised to see that anyone with a contrary view to that majority is being shut down.
I now consider myself shut down and leave will you all to blame everyone else for the ills of this society as I much prefer to do something about any bad situation that I find myself in rather than just wallow in misery and apathy waiting for someone else to sort things out for me.